‘When discussing the struggles of working-class communities, why are British Muslims ignored?’

Writer Taj Ali explores how British Muslims are invisibilised from the discourse on social class in Britain and asks why the political and media class are quick to dismiss their struggles.

In the aftermath of the 2019 General Election, when the Conservative Party received a landslide majority of 80 seats and the Labour Party won its lowest number of seats since 1935, a great deal of discussion took place regarding working-class voters abandoning the Labour Party.  

Voters in the infamous ‘Red Wall’ constituencies, many of whom had supported Brexit, left the Labour Party in their droves. Commentators rightly said that political parties must listen and engage with these disillusioned voters. A great deal of political analysis took place, trying to understand why white working-class voters in particular were moving away from the Labour Party.

It’s not the first time the phrase ‘white working class’ has been mentioned in conversations around socio-economic inequality in Britain. It’s become a regular staple in the rhetoric around disadvantage in the UK and is often used cynically by some to pit communities against one another.  

In contrast, we very rarely discuss the struggles of the Black working class or the South Asian working class despite many ethnic minority communities being disproportionately from those backgrounds. We are even less likely to hear the phrase Muslim working class as a phrase. These omissions obscure the reality that the working class in Britain is multi-racial and, indeed, multi-faith.

Working-class British Muslims  

British Muslims remain largely invisibilised from the discourse surrounding traditional working-class communities despite many residing in areas that have suffered from deindustrialisation, austerity cuts to public services and have been disproportionately affected by Covid-19 and the cost of living crisis.  

According to the last census, almost half of the Muslim population resides in the bottom 10% of the most deprived Local Authority Districts in England. British Muslims experience the lowest earnings of any religious group, earning £350 less each month than the average.

When we look at outcomes for Muslim majority ethnic groups, these disparities and inequalities become clearer. British Pakistani and Bangladeshi children, for instance, have the highest rates of child poverty in the UK at 54% and 59% respectively. Workers of Pakistani and Bangladeshi heritage have the lowest median hourly pay of any ethnic group, in the latter case earning 20.1% less than white workers.

Many socioeconomic issues such as child poverty, poor social housing and inequalities in health and educational outcomes are issues that British Muslims are affected by and deeply passionate about tackling. The notion that Muslims only care about foreign policy issues couldn’t be further from the truth.  

In my hometown of Luton, home to a very large Muslim community, the child poverty rate is a jaw-dropping 46%. We have the highest homelessness rate outside of London with 1 in 66 people classified as homeless. And across the country, from Bradford to Brick Lane, many British Muslims are struggling.

Just a few months ago, Muslim charities Islamic Relief and the National Zakat Foundation warned that the increasing cost of living was driving UK Muslims deeper into poverty. Towards the end of March, the National Zakat Foundation said requests for help from its hardship fund had soared by 70% over the last twelve months.

Engaging and understanding British Muslims

There has been very little effort by political parties and media outlets to engage and understand the struggles of British Muslims. The Batley and Spen by-election is a case in point. In 2017, the Labour Party won the seat with over 55% of the vote and a majority of 8,000. In 2019, this majority was slashed to around 3,500 and at a by-election last year, the seat was won with only 35% of the vote and a wafer-thin majority of 323.

Muslims make up 20% of the constituency of Batley and Spen and much was made of the disillusionment that many British Muslims felt towards the Labour Party. Rather than engaging and listening, Muslim voters were smeared and demonised by party officials and media outlets. It emerged that a senior Labour party official had briefed the Daily Mail that Muslims were deserting the Labour Party because Keir Starmer was tackling anti-Semitism in the party. The Labour Muslim network called it a “patently vile, Islamophobic briefing.”

When Labour lost support among white working-class voters, political commentators and party officials said, rightly, that the party must do more to engage with these voters and win back their trust. And yet when it came to the Muslim voters of Batley, that same courtesy was never extended. There were no focus groups, no detailed inquiries and no genuine efforts to listen to and learn from British Muslims, who make up a significant part of Labour’s traditional working-class heartlands.

Far too often, race, class and religion are counter-posed as if they are mutually exclusive and not intrinsically interlinked. The discourse on economic disparities and disadvantages in modern Britain must reflect those most affected by them and the solutions to tackle these inequalities must encompass them too.

Taj Ali is a writer with an interest in class and socio-economic inequality. His work has appeared in the Huffington Post, Metro and the Independent. He’s on Twitter at @taj_ali1

Opinions expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily represent the views of Islam Channel or its editorial policy.

FUND HONEST INDEPENDENT MUSLIM JOURNALISM

Donate today and help us tell the stories that matter. Together we can make a difference

Donate today and help us tell the stories that matter.
Together we can make a difference

The mainstream media has been justifying genocide in Gaza. Islamophobia and censorship are the norm. We're changing that. Our journalism has reached over 300M impressions on social media since October 7th. On TV, our rolling news coverage has featured key figures like Husam Zomlot, Avi Shlaim, Gideon Levy and Jeremy Corbyn.

We need your support to reveal the truth and ensure our voices are heard. Donate today.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

TOP STORIES

RELATED STORIES

DONATE TO GOOD CAUSES
THIS DHUL HIJJAH

DONATE TO GOOD
CAUSES THIS DHUL HIJJAH

Give your
zakat and
sadaqah
to trusted charities.

Give your zakat and sadaqah to trusted charities.

Our 100% donation policy means every penny goes directly to your favourite charities.

Automate your donations over the first 10 days of Dhul Hijjah and make the most of these blessed days

CONTACT INFORMATION

Islam Channel
Media House
428-432 Ley Street
London
IG2 7BS

+(44) 207 374 4511